Disclaimer: I do not own Arrow or anything to do with DC. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.
Author's note: This story takes place after Season 2, but has it's own continuity.
Keywords: Anal, DP, FF+, Oral, Rim, Toys
Arrow: Stuffed Canary Part 4
by MTL ([email protected])
Thea Queen had always considered herself straight. Mostly. Growing up there had been the occasional fantasy, but mostly she thought about men and she only ever dated them. Although she had never loved any of them until Roy. Oh how she missed Roy. But his forced exile was just one of the many changes in her life which led her to be on the back of a motorcycle and clinging onto Sara Lance while dressed in all red and questioning her sexuality. Actually she had been doing that last thing ever since her brother had finally told her the truth about his life as a vigilante, and revealed that the women surrounding him weren't just beautiful, they were bad ass superheroes.
Which had skyrocketed her passing interest in them, especially now Roy wasn't around to distract her from her curiosity. And Sara did smell so good. Sweaty, but good. And now she got to watch the likes of Sara and Nyssa al Ghul effortlessly kick the asses of the local scumbags Thea felt her crushes on these women grow and grow. But she had to control herself, because Sara was already dating Felicity, who was equally bad ass in her own right, and she was pretty sure Nyssa was dating Laurel. Which was why Thea was so shocked when she and Sara reached their HQ only to find Nyssa with her hand down Felicity's skirt.
"Guys! We've talked about this. No sex in the Arrow cave." Sara smirked as her girlfriends quickly pulled away from each other. Or more accurately a clearly annoyed Felicity pushed Nyssa away, prompting Sara's smirk to become even more wicked.
"She started it!" Felicity whined.
"I don't doubt it." Sara grinned, "But I'd expect that from her. Or me. You're supposed to be the one to keep us both in line."
Blushing furiously Felicity protested, "But, but... I thought you weren't coming back. You know, like Oliver and Dig."
Sara shrugged, "We searched the parameter, but we couldn't find anything, so we decided to head back."
"Without informing me!" Felicity snapped.
"Erm, guys... what's going on?" Thea finally asked after a few long seconds of being completely dumbfounded.
"We... erm... we..." Felicity quickly jumped in and then panicking when everybody looked at her and she had suddenly had no idea what she had been going to say, if indeed she had something in the first place. Either way, there was a deafening silence and then she squeaked, "We, have an arrangement."
"An arrangement?" Thea frowned.
"Indeed." Nyssa confirmed with a smile which made Thea blush and turn her gaze away from her.
"It's no big deal." Sara said nonchalantly, unable to keep that tone of voice as she awkwardly added, "We're just... dating."
"What, like... all three of you?" Thea asked in disbelief and the other three women just nodded, although some more boldly than others, pretty much freaking her out, "And that's no big deal to you?"
"Why should it be?" Nyssa asked, "In The League the reigning Ra's al Ghul often takes many wives and lovers."
"This isn't The League!" Felicity pointed out flatly, briefly glaring at her brunette girlfriend before turning back to Thea, "I'm sorry you found out like this. We were going to tell you eventually, it's just, this is kind of new. The polyamorous part at least. Me and Sara were together before that. For awhile actually. Which you, erm, knew, so... erm..."
"I think she gets it sweetie. " Sara said softly as a way to gently cut off her rambling lover, although she never looked away from Thea, "We were going to tell you eventually. It's just all kind of new."
"And weird. We get that it's weird. Well, Nyssa doesn't think so, but she was raised by wolves." Felicity chimed in.
"I was not-" Nyssa began indignantly.
"The point is..." Sara quickly interrupted, "We're sorry we didn't tell you, and we hope this doesn't freak you out too much. And if you have any questions, now is the time to ask."
There was a long pause and then Thea croaked, "Does Oli know?"
"No." All three other women more or less said together.
"Sooooo..." Thea began, briefly hesitating but she just couldn't stop blurting out, "Are you three, you know... monogamous?"
"Yes." Felicity replied quickly and without hesitation.
Meanwhile Sara frowned, "Why do you ask?"
"Why indeed." Nyssa grinned wickedly.
"I, I... I..." Thea started while blushing furiously.
"Could it be that Miss Queen wants to join us?" Nyssa grinned while walking forward menacingly.
"No, no, no, get your mind out of the gutter Nyssa." Felicity scolded, "Of course she doesn't want to join us."
"I kinda do." Thea admitted softly, although her words sounded deafening, especially as everybody went silent.
Felicity also froze, turned away from Nyssa to Thea and then mumbled in disbelief, "You what now?"
"Sorry." Thea blushed.
"But, but... but you're straight!" Felicity blurted out.
"Mostly." Thea nodded, then letting out a laugh as she admitted, "But you're all just so fucking hot."
"Well, I think that settles it." Nyssa smiled.
Sara's eyes went wide, "That does not settled. For God sakes Nyssa, she's just a kid."
"I'm not just a kid!" Thea said angrily, before her eyes went wide, "Wait, are you actually offering me a four way? Like seriously? Because if you are I'm so down for it."
Turning to the younger girl Sara pointed out, "I used to babysit you!"
"Yeah, and I've had a huge crush on you ever since." Thea admitted, and then blushed because she didn't mean too.
There was a pause and then Sara looked at Felicity guiltily, the other two doing the same without the guilt, causing Felicity to go postal, "You can't be serious?"
"Why not?" Nyssa asked.
"Because it's wrong!" Felicity blurted out, feeling like she was the one going crazy, "She's Oliver's sister!"
"So?" Sara replied nonchalantly, "Oli didn't care about crossing that line when he was flip-flopping between me and Laurel."
"This would be different, and you know it." Felicity pointed out.
"In some ways." Sara admitted, before quickly adding, "But in others not, and all things considered he doesn't really have a right to judge. So if he ever finds out, and I think we can all agree none of us want that to happen, but if he does he can be mad for a while, but he should accepted as karma and move on. And if he doesn't, well, he'd be lost without the three of us. Or more accurately you. So he'd have to get over it sooner or later."
There was a long pause and then Felicity mumbled, "I, I thought we were going to be monogamous."
"Ha, you Americans and your monogamy." Nyssa scoffed, before quickly adding, "I'm not suggesting she join us permanently. Just for the night. Which I assume is what she and Sara want."
There was a chorus of nodding, another even longer pause, then Felicity protested, "But she's-"
"Just a kid?" Thea offered, "So what? At 20 I'm old enough to put on a mask and run around shooting people with arrows, but not to have group sex? What kind of insane logic is that?"
"I was going to say we work with you, but that's equally stupid given who I'm dating." Felicity grumbled, followed by more silence.
"Felicity." Thea sighed, before moving forward until she was right in front of Felicity and then softening her tone, "Look, I want this. I want you. All of you. So, so bad. I've literally dreamt of it. The three of you ganging up on me. Having your way with me. Turning me into a little fuck toy. So please just do it. Or agreed to watching Nyssa and Sara do it. Please Felicity? I'll do anything if you'll let me be your fuck toy?"
As she spoke Thea slowly got down on her knees in front of Felicity while looking up at her pleadingly, and she stayed there for what felt an eternity when she was done talking as Felicity just stared back. Then Felicity softly said, "Oh God, let's all go back to my place before I chicken out."
There was a chorus of happy sounds from the other three women, Sara closing the distance and leaning in, "I promise you won't regret this babe."
Felicity blushed, and then frowned at her girlfriends, "I'm holding you to that. Both of you."
* * *
The ride to Felicity's and Sara's apartment, which they apparently now shared with Nyssa, was surreal and thankfully quick. Thea wasn't as good at reading people as Nyssa and Sara, who were usually good at hiding their emotions anyway, but she was pretty sure everybody found it weird and were relieved when it was over. Especially Felicity who everyone could really was an open book, Thea silently wondering how she had ever kept her brother's secret for so long if she was this bad at playing it cool. Then she got very distracted by Nyssa, who apparently wasn't just grateful that the awkward/silent drive was done with, given that as soon as the door to the apartment was closed and locked the assassin pulled Thea into her arms and kissed her.
It was surprisingly gentle, which was probably for Thea's benefit. Trying to show that was unnecessary Thea kissed back eagerly, wrapping her arms around Nyssa trying to push her tongue into the other woman's mouth. Sadly Nyssa didn't respond to that like she hoped, and gently but firmly forced Thea to slow her role. Which was disappointing, although Thea didn't exactly complain. After all, she had dreamt of kissing Nyssa, and the two now watching blondes, for years and is eager as she was to do this, and more, Thea did like taking a minute to savour the moment. And Nyssa did eventually allowed tongues into the mix, it was just on her terms. More specifically her tongue invading Thea's mouth, leaving Thea to massaged it with her own.
Sara was amused at seeing this. Nyssa always had to be the top. Even on the rare occasions she and/or Felicity were able to talk her into bottoming she still tried to take control, and it was adorable watching Thea trying to take that from her only to be put in her place. Adorable, and extremely hot. Which only helped Sara look at Thea in a way she never had before. Well, there may have been the occasional glance when she first returned to Starling city, as five years later after last seeing each other Thea had changed from a pretty teenager to a beautiful young woman. However she had always felt out of bounds. Besides, Thea had Rory while Sara struggled to keep her eyes off of Felicity.
It was hard to take her eyes off two beautiful women kissing, but Sara just about managed it to check in on the only source of light in her world. Then she couldn't help but smile, because Felicity had the same look of embarrassed lust she'd had during the first few threesomes with Nyssa, which was just so cute. It was also a encouraging sign that Felicity would ultimately be all right with this, although not as much as the nerdy girl turning to her and giving her a bashful smile. Sara returned it with a happy one of her own before turning back to her other girlfriend and her soon to be new lover, confident as she could be that Felicity wasn't freaking out.
She turned just in time to see Nyssa break the kiss and look expectantly at Thea. The younger woman gasped breathlessly, but after a few long seconds smiled wickedly at the older woman. Nyssa smiled back, turned Thea around in her arms and wordlessly pushed her towards Sara. Taking the hint Sara moved forward and extended her arms to grab Thea, the youngest vigilante in their group smiling again before practically running into the Canary's arms. Thea then kissed Sara roughly, only to quickly learn that like Nyssa before her Sara would only accept a gentle kiss, at least for now, the blonde thrilled that the brunette quickly submitted to her like she had Nyssa.
Part of her, a very big part actually, wanted to kiss Thea just as roughly as Thea apparently wanted her too, but they had all night and Sara had no intention of rushing it. So she waited several minutes before pushing her tongue into Thea's mouth, and even when she did it wasn't that long before Sara broke the kiss and repeated what Nyssa had just done, making sure to give Thea a little time to recover before passing her back to Nyssa. She didn't always, Nyssa moving in closer so that she and Sara could pass Thea around like the little toy the younger girl had confessed she wanted to be, and to delight there wasn't even a hint of complaining from Thea. Or Felicity for that matter.
Turning her attention to their other girlfriend Nyssa asked, "Would you like a turn sweetie?"
Which of course made Felicity blush adorably, "I'm, I'm fine. Just keep going. Please?"
Nyssa smiled at Felicity and then pulled Thea in for another deep kiss, she and Sara sharing the 20 year old for a few more minutes before she pushed her back and ordered her, "Strip for us."
Thea hesitated, but only because she was deciding how best to do this. She had practised stripping in front of the mirror many times, and while her practiced routine had been a big hit with Roy he was a guy and therefore really easy to please. This, this was different. This was three experienced women, who probably wouldn't be as impressed as one horny boy. More to the point while she had practised taking off skirts, dresses and jeans in a sexy way she hadn't done the same with her super suit, which was meant more to mirror her brother's attire than look sexy, so not only would trying to remove it sexily be difficult but it would also be kind of icky. So she went with her first instinct and practically ripped the costume off of herself, practical and unsexy underwear and all, as quickly as she could.
Once the younger brunette was awkwardly standing naked in front of her Nyssa ordered, "On your knees."
Sara opened her mouth to protest, but before she could Thea fell to her knees, causing her to change tactics, "Nyssa, let's not be too rough with the kid, okay?"
"Oh, I don't think she minds, do you Thea?" Nyssa smiled wickedly, slowly advancing on her pray and then walking around her.
"No." Thea nodded, leaning into the touch as Nyssa rewarded her by gently stroking her hair, "Do whatever you want with me."
"Awww, isn't that sweet?" Nyssa grinned.
Ignoring her girlfriend Sara firmly told her friend, "Thea, if you ever want us to slow things down, or even stop, just tell us. I promise we won't be mad. Okay?"
"Okay." Thea nodded, happy to be given an out even if she didn't want it.
"Good, now that's settled..." Nyssa smiled, "Thea, have you ever eaten pussy before?"
Thea blushed as she replied truthfully, "No?"
Nyssa smiled knowingly, "Would you like to eat Sara's?"
"More than anything." Thea admitted softly.
"Then beg for it." Nyssa pushed, "Beg for the privilege of eating Sara's pussy. Mmmmm, and trust me it is a privilege. As I and Felicity know so well."
Felicity blushed at Nyssa's words, and the way Nyssa looked at her, but not as much as when Thea began to shamelessly begged, "Please can I eat Sara's pussy. I want it so bad. Please Sara, let me eat your pussy. Please? Please allow me the privilege of pleasing you with my tongue. I, I don't really know how, but I'll figure it out. I promise. Or you can tell me what you like. Or Nyssa can. Whatever, I don't care, I just want to eat your pussy. Please Sara, please let me eat you out. Let me lick you, then Nyssa, then Felicity, mmmmmm, I want to lick you all! I want to lick all your pussies and be your little pussy eating lesbian slut."
There was a long moment of silence and then Sara smirked, "Well, since you asked so nicely."
With that Sara started slowly stripping off her clothes, easily putting Thea to shame. To be fair while Thea's outfit was designed to be more practical than sexy Sara's was exactly the opposite, which was understandable. If Thea had tits like that she'd definitely be using them as weapons, both on the people she fought and tried to seduce. Same went for that booty. Well, Thea thought she had a pretty good butt, even though it wasn't in the same league as Sara's, Thea very much hoping she would get to play with those assets sometime in the future. And if she had to do a good job at eating Sara's pussy to get that privilege then she would do so happily, Thea thought as she struggled not to drool as Sara removed the last of her clothing.
For a few seconds Sara stood there in all her glory, allowing Thea to admire it before raising an eyebrow and smirking, "Well, don't you want what you begged for?"
"Right, sorry, it's just... you're so beautiful." Thea blushed, quickly shuffling forward.
"Awww, thanks sweetie." Sara smiled.
When she reached her destination Thea bit her lip, then deciding to push her luck looked up at Sara and asked, "Can I play with your tits a little first?"
Sara smiled again, "Of course."
Then Sara bent down and Thea reached up to eagerly grabbed two handfuls of the other girl's boobs, for the first time touching another woman intimately. Touching Sara Lance intimately, that fact along with the action itself causing Thea's heart to hammer in her chest. It certainly didn't calm down as she did her best to do what she liked, caressing both breasts for a few long seconds with her hands before taking one nipple into her mouth and gently sucking on it. This got a encouraging little gasp out of Sara so Thea did the same to the other nipple, except this time she also swirled her tongue around it before she began to suck it.
Over and over again Thea went back and forth between those nipples, sometimes kissing the flesh around them and other times going straight for them, but always licking and sucking them eagerly. And even though the position wasn't particularly comfortable for either of them Sara allowed her to do this for quite a while before straightening up and gently guiding Thea's face in between her legs. Once she was back at her ultimate destination Thea hesitated only for a brief second because of pure nervousness before leaning forward, closing her eyes and sticking out her tongue while silently praying she would do a good job. She never even thought she wouldn't like it, and the second Sara's flavour hit her taste-buds she was proven right.
Sara let out another little gasp of pleasure as Thea's nervous but eager tongue pressed against the bottom of her pussy and then slowly slid all the way up to the top before then repeating the process, squeezing more gasps out of Sara. Soon after she began moaning and occasionally swearing in pleasure too, partly to encourage the nervous pussy licker, and partly because Thea wasn't at all bad for her first time. Plus this was still Oliver's little sister, and a girl only just out of her teens, so having her on her knees in front of Sara and slowly but eagerly licking her cunt was beyond intoxicating. And wrong. Not that Sara really felt bad for Oli given their complicated history, but given that history this still felt wrong, which was one of the reasons it felt so good.
Soon Sara was closing her eyes because she just couldn't cope with the intensity of looking down and seeing little Thea Queen in between her legs. It was also part of a reaction which also included tilting her head back and letting out an extra loud moan as for the first time Thea cautiously lingered on her clit. She had been gently hitting it with pretty much every stroke of her tongue, but after such a positive reaction Thea went after it with a vengeance, not just rapidly licking it but wrapping her lips around it and sucking it. Leaving Sara with a choice. Even if she could let Thea keep going and cum quickly, SHE could stop her and draw this out a little bit.
It was a tough choice, but ultimately Sara opened her eyes, reached down, grabbed a firm hold of Thea's hair and gently pushed her downwards while telling her, "Not so fast sweetie. There's no rush."
"Sorry." Thea apologise nervously.
"Oh no, don't be sorry honey. Just slow down." Sara said softly, "We've got all night, and I want to enjoy this."
"Don't we all." Nyssa chimed in, slowly closing the distance between herself and Sara.
Smiling happily Sara reached out and pulled Nyssa firmly into her with one arm while one brunette wrapped her arms around her and kissed her and the other brunette returned to her pussy licking duties. Sara then enjoyed a slow, sweet kiss with Nyssa for several minutes, which was so consuming she almost didn't notice Thea nervously sliding her hands up her thighs and around to squeeze her ass. Not that Sara minded, especially as it coincided with Thea wrapping her lips around Sara's pussy lips and sucking them gently, proving that she had in fact researched this. Or she was lying to them and had done this before, although Sara suspected the former.
That was why she continued to encourage Thea, first by gently pushing her head deeper into her cunt, and then eventually breaking the kiss with Nyssa so she could moan, "Oh God Thea, that's it! Mmmmm, eat me! Eat my cunt. Oooooooh baby, that's it, lick me just like that. Now suck it, suck my pussy lips just like that, ohhhhhhhh Thea, your even better than your brother."
"Sara!" Felicity exclaimed.
Sara hadn't meant to say that, as she initially looked apologetic at Felicity and then at Thea, but she stopped short of actually apologising when she saw the look on Thea's face. There was clearly a moment of debate, then she started licking Sara even more thoroughly than before, which caused the Canary to smile wickedly. She had expected Thea was a girl after her own heart back when she was babysitting for her, but apparently she had no idea just how much she was, because the younger brunette seemed to delight in being told that she was better than her brother at eating pussy, Sara really wanting to elaborate in that moment, but deciding against it for Felicity's sake. And apparently no one else in the room.
Nyssa would certainly have like to hear Sara elaborate, but she understood they were walking a fine line, at least at the moment. But hopefully not for very much longer, because Nyssa had been trained to be observant and she liked to think in a short amount of time she had got to know Felicity Smoak very well, and could tell when she wanted to do something. Even if every ounce of her relevant training wasn't telling Nyssa that Felicity wanted to join the fun, or at least such herself. Quietly confident that it was only a matter of time Nyssa mostly concentrated on making Sara feel good watching the pretty little first-time pussy licker in between the legs of her beloved.
That was until Sara broke their latest kiss and very generously offered her, "Would you like a turn with this hot little slut's tongue?"
"Of course." Nyssa smiled sweetly, before reaching down in between Sara's legs, grabbing Thea's hair and forcefully pulling the younger brunette from the blonde's pussy to her own while firmly ordering, "Eat me! Eat my pussy you little ooooooooh yesssssssssss!"
Before Nyssa could even complete the order Thea started eagerly lapping away at her pussy, causing Nyssa to lose her train of thought as she closed her eyes and moaned in approval. She then opened her mouth to continue the encouragement, but before she could get a word out she was being kissed again by an eager tongue she would know anywhere. Of course she eagerly kissed back, and silently admitted it was probably for the best that Sara had silenced her, given the fragile state the watching Felicity was currently in. So she chose to show her approval in other ways, namely by gently stroking Thea's hair as the inexperienced but eager girl continued licking her pussy.
It was very rare that Nyssa would shove a first timers face in between her legs and bark orders at her, but Thea was a very special case, and Nyssa's guessed that this would be more than okay with it was quickly proven right. If anything it was too effective at encouraging the inexperienced girl as Thea not only started giving her quick licks but made sure her tongue hit Nyssa's clit every single time. Which in itself Nyssa was hesitant to stop given how good it felt, but she to wanted this to last. After all, this wasn't just any first-timer, this was the sister of the irritating and self-righteous Oliver Queen, and Thea was a worthy ally in her own right, so the last thing Nyssa wanted to do was rush this.
Which was why Nyssa did ultimately break the kiss with Sara, look down and firmly tell Thea, "I believe my beloved told you there was no rush."
"I'm sorry, you just taste so good." Thea apologised, briefly pulling her face from Nyssa's pussy
"I know." Nyssa said dismissively, before pushing Thea's face back where it belonged, "Now get back to eating my cunt. I don't want you to make me cum just yet, but I certainly don't want you to stop. Ohhhhhhh yes, lick me you little bitch! Oh fuck, That's right, not to slow and not too fast, just the right amount of pussy licking, mmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhh."
"Nyssa, take it easy on the kid." Sara whispered into her ear before going back to what she was doing before, namely kissing Nyssa's neck.
As they both knew that it was for Felicity's benefit Nyssa did indeed take it easy on the kid, although Thea was quickly proving she was no mere child. Well, she had proved that many times before in battle, but this was far more pleasurable. So wonderfully pleasurable. So much so that the desire to be greedy and hog this hot little mouth became increasingly tempting. But Nyssa was a good girlfriend, something she felt she proved nicely by silently pulling Thea's head from in between her thighs and then pushing it in between Sara's, all without breaking the kiss, to Nyssa's delight Thea seemingly happy to be passed back and forth like a good little lesbian fuck toy.
Thea loved being used like this. It was everything she dreamt about and more, because as much as she tried her imagination hadn't done justice to the taste of pussy. Especially not the taste of the pussies of Sara Lance and Nyssa al Ghul. Oh God, she still couldn't believe she was going down on Sara Lance and Nyssa al Ghul. Fingering herself and tasting it just couldn't compare with doing what she dreamt of for so long, and not just getting to do it but doing a good enough job to make these strong, beautiful women moan in pleasure for her. Fuck, it was so overwhelming. The only way it could be better was if Felicity joined them, and clearly she wasn't the only one who wanted that.
"Are you sure you don't want a turn baby?" Sara asked Felicity.
"N, n, no." Felicity stammered, not really convincing even herself.
"No you don't want a turn, or know you're not sure if you don't want a turn?" Nyssa pushed with a sly smile.
"No, I don't want a turn..." Felicity clarified, almost adding the words 'not yet'. Instead she quickly added, "But I... I do wanna see you cum in her face. Both of you."
"No problem babe." Sara grinned wickedly, before looking down to the girl in between her legs, "You heard my girl, make me cum! Ooooooooh yeah, push your tongue into my cunt and make me cum. Oh Thea, mmmmmm, fuck me Thea. Fuck me! Ohhhhhhhh shit, I wanna cum all over Oli's sister's pretty little face. Oh fuck, make me cum, make me fucking cum, ooooooohhhhhhhh yeeeeeesssssss, oh fuck!"
For a few long seconds Thea was too dumbstruck by Sara Lance begging her to make her cum. Or more accurately ordering her to make her cum. Either way it was overwhelming, so much so that it took her a while to respond, considering she had been wanting to do this for what felt like forever. Hopefully she made up for it by ramming her tongue as deep into Sara's pussy as it would go and then beginning to tongue fuck the other woman. It certainly took away Sara's ability to speak coherently, which was a very good sign, but nowhere near as good as the heaven which came next, which was namely the flavour of Sara's cum hitting her taste-buds.
This made Thea whimper with joy. Soon as she tasted Sara's regular cream Thea hadn't thought there could be anything better, but she was overjoyed to be proven wrong as her mouth was filled with the most heavenly liquid she had ever known. She was so overwhelmed by it that a lot of that amazing liquid escaped, prompting Thea to desperately start swallowing Sara's cum, but it was no use, the other girl was just cumming so much, and she was grinding against her face while doing it. Then it was over and Thea felt like she needed more girl cum like she needed oxygen, so she frantically tongue fucked Sara to another climax, and then another, and another, and then another.
Just as she was getting tired Thea was given a short break. As in a few seconds while Nyssa forced her to switch back to the pussy of the Heir of the Demon with the words, "My turn bitch! Make me cum!"
Honestly Thea was sure that Nyssa said more, probably a lot more, but she was so focused on making her cum that she really didn't notice. It didn't help matters that unlike Sara who had been nice enough to mostly stay still and allow Thea to swallow her cum Nyssa started grinding against her face after her first orgasm. She started out gentle enough, but it wasn't long before Nyssa was fucking her face so roughly that Thea was struggling to breathe, let alone swallow cum. Which made Thea feel like a failure as a fuck toy. Because really, how could she allow all that precious girl cum to go to waste? Then again the fact another girl was cuming in her face was so hot, Thea feeling like Nyssa was marking her as a pussy loving slut, drenching her face so much that other women would always know what kind of slut she truly was.
Nyssa was tempted to make the cute little lesbian eat pussy all night long, but she had never been that selfish a lover, so after the latest in a long line of powerful orgasms she turned to Sara and suggested, "Ooooooh Sara, I think, mmmmm, I think our little slut has earned herself a reward, don't you?"
"Way ahead of you babe." Sara grinned, holding up the two strap-on dildos she had retrieved while Nyssa was having her turn.
"Excellent." Nyssa beamed, pulling Sara into a quick kiss before pushing Thea away, grabbing hold of the dildos and holding them out to the younger brunette, "Strap them to us."
After a few seconds gasping for breath Thea grinned wickedly, "Yes Mistress."
Sara allowed a small smile to cross her face at those words, then turned her attention to Felicity, "Do you want one babe?"
"No." Felicity blushed, not taking her eyes off Thea as she rushed to obey, "I'm good."
"Are you sure?" Sara gently pushed, before pointing out, "You could lay down so Thea could ride you, that way you wouldn't have to do anything. Mmmmmm, and we could make her air tight."
"I'd, I'd still rather just watch. But please, please double stuff her." Felicity practically begged, before smirking, "Make her your stuffed Queen."
"Oh don't worry, we will." Nyssa promised with a wicked grin, then once the cocks were in place she looked down at Thea and added, "But first let's get them wet. I assume you've sucked cock before, so let's see what your precious boyfriend Roy left behind."
Nyssa instantly regretted mentioning Thea's ex. She hadn't known him that long but he was good to Thea and Team Arrow missed him very much, although none more than Thea who looked taken aback from the namedrop. It was almost enough to make Nyssa apologise, which Sara could explain was extremely rare, but luckily that wasn't necessary. Instead after a few seconds of hesitation Thea grabbed both dildos by the base and began stroking them like they were real before taking Nyssa's cock into her mouth and beginning to bob her head rapidly up and down. Then she moved to Sara's cock and did the same, going back and forth between those dildos to make sure they were nice and wet. Pretty much the entire time Nyssa wanted to provide a little commentary, but she didn't trust her own voice after that last comment.
Luckily Sara didn't have the same concern, "Oh yeah, that's it Thea, suck my cock! Take it deep into that pretty mouth which just made me cum so hard and get it nice and wet so I can fuck you. Yes, now do Nyssa. Yessssss, suck Nyssa's cock! Take it deep down your slutty little throat! What, you've never deep throated before? Yeah, that's what I thought. That's what I fucking thought. Now back to me. I want some of that deep throat action. Yeahhhhhh, take it deep. Come on, deeper, deeper, that's it, deeper, ooooooooh, good girl. That's real good Thea. I'm so proud of you. You're turning out to be a really good cock sucker for us."
Those words made Nyssa smirk and gave her the confidence to gently grab hold of the back of Thea's head and push her deeper down the dick when it was her turn once again for a little head. Sara quickly followed suit and they began to encourage Thea to take the dildos almost all the way down her throat. Sadly she just couldn't get the last little bit, although Nyssa silently promise that one day soon she would. Oh yes, someday soon Thea would be a Sara Lance calibre of cock sucker. For now she simply gently encouraged Thea to lick the lower parts of the cocks, which the little slut eagerly did while looking up at them pleadingly, Thea obviously more than ready to get fucked. And oh, was she about to get her wish.
"So, which of this pretty little fuck holes do you want?" Nyssa eventually asked almost conversationally.
Instead of answering Sara kneeled down, gently pulled Thea away from Nyssa's cock and while gently stroking her face asked, "Thea, have you ever been butt fucked?"
Thea shook her head and softly replied, "No."
"Would you like to be?" Sara gently pushed.
There was a brief silence and then Felicity butted in, "I know it seems scary, God knows I was when Sara took my anal cherry, and when these two DP'ed me for the first time, but trust me it's worth it for the orgasms. Especially if the other has her strap-on in your pussy at the same time, because wow, is that awesome."
Sara and Nyssa turned to smile at Felicity with affection, but Thea kept her eyes on Sara until she turned back to face her and then she softly asked, "Could you do it?"
"Absolutely." Sara grinned, "It would be an honour."
"I guess I get her pussy then." Nyssa said, striding over to the bed and getting into the centre of it, "Come along girl, do you want to get fucked or not."
Thea blushed adorably and glanced at first Nyssa, then Sara, who quickly told her, "Felicity's right. It will be easier on you, and feel amazing."
"Okay." Thea said softly, finally getting off her knees and scrambling to get into position.
Thea's eagerness made Nyssa smirk, although not as much as the obvious nervousness and the way that Thea blushed and couldn't look her in the eye at first, despite what they had already done. To be fair Thea got a little braver when she was in position, the younger girl pushing herself down without hesitation onto Nyssa's cock, which Nyssa graciously held in place while Thea concentrated on getting that cock into her pussy. It turned out to be quite easy, which wasn't surprising given how eager Thea had been to eat pussy, that privilege making her little cunt wet and ready to be fucked. Also while it hadn't been up to Sara's standard Thea had given quite the respectable blow job for a girl her age.
When that big dick slipped inside her little cunt Thea close her eyes, threw her head back slightly and let out a long moan of pleasure. Then she opened her eyes again and smiled down at Nyssa like the good little slut Nyssa knew she could be. No, on second thoughts in this moment Thea was just a woman satisfying her needs without shame, and was beautiful. Nyssa very much looked forward to when Thea would truly act like a slut and take two big strap-on cocks inside her, but for now it truly felt enchanting to watch Thea slowly but confidently pushing her self all the way down the dick and then beginning to bounce up and down while continuing to moan, groan and whimper happily.
After a few minutes of just watching this glorious sight Sara called out with a smirk, "Felicity honey, could you grab the lube for me."
"Su, sure." Felicity blushed, pulling her hand out of her skirt like a kid with their hand caught in the cookie jar.
Sara beamed at that reaction, although she quickly looked away and focused on Thea's cute little backside again, causing her smile to fade into a look of burning lust as she slowly approached her pray. Once she reached her destination Thea understandably tensed up, but thankfully relaxed as Sara softly cooed and stroked her back. She then briefly continued the soothing cooing after allowing her hand to slide to Thea's ass, although it didn't take long for the girl to relax and stop her bouncing to allow Sara to do what was necessary to prepare Thea to lose her anal virginity, with a little help from Felicity who quickly appeared by Sara's side and held out a tube of lubricant for her.
"I got it!" Felicity announced.
Sara smiled, grabbed Felicity's hand and pulled her into a deep kiss which lasted maybe a full minute, then she broke it and firmly told her lover, "Take off all your clothes and start fingering yourself."
"Okay." Felicity squeaked.
Ignoring the other blonde Sara grabbed the lube with one hand and then use the other to smack Thea's butt roughly enough to cause the younger girl to cry out, and then she firmly ordered, "And as for you, spread your cheeks and show me that pretty little virgin hole!"
In a flash Thea reached back and pulled her ass cheeks as wide apart as possible, giving Sara the best possible view of Nyssa's dildo stretching Thea's cunt and above it the cute little virgin butt hole that Sara was about to violate. It was such a stunning view that Sara took a long second or two just to enjoy it before squirting a generous amount of lubricant onto her right hand, using her left to rub it into her fingers before reaching down and starting to gently caress Thea's ass. When this didn't cause Thea to tense up Sara pushed one and then two fingers into that incredibly tight hole, causing the other girl to gasp and moan in mostly pleasure.
"So, is she tight?" Nyssa asked with a wicked grin on her face.
"Virgin tight." Sara grinned, confirming Thea had been telling the truth while gently teasing the poor girl. Then after a few moments of anally fingering the younger girl Sara pulled her fingers out and replace them with her cock, briefly sliding it up and down Thea's ass crack as she taunted the younger brunette, "The real question is, is this what she really wants?"
"God yes, please Sara, fuck me." Thea whimpered, saying whatever she thought would get her what she wanted, "Fuck my virgin ass! Pop my anal cherry. Mmmmmm, be the first to take my tight little butt."
Sara smirked, "Not bad, but I think you can do better."
Taking the hint Thea got increasingly graphic, "Fuck my ass! Please fuck my virgin ass! Pop my butt cherry, take my anal virginity, fucking wreck my tight little virgin ass! Please Sara, I wanna be butt fucked by you. I want my former babysitter to fuck me up the butt. I want my brother's ex-girlfriend to pound my tight little virgin butt and make me her fucking butt slut! Fuck my ass Sara! Fuck it and make me love it, I have always wanted you too. Mmmmmm yeah, ass fuck me in front of your girlfriend. I mean girlfriends. Oh fuck, I mean fuck me in the ass while one of your girlfriend watches and the other fucks my pussy. Ohhhhhh yeahhhhh, DP me like a whore, OH GOD!"
At the end of that little speech Thea let out a loud cry as her ass hole was stretched for the first time by an invading force, Sara almost taking her friend's butt cherry with one hard thrust. She was certainly tempted, but it probably wasn't the best thing for Thea. Besides, this way she got to savour the sight of Thea's virgin ass hole stretching around the head of her cock, Sara making it stretch wider, and wider, and wider until it allow the head of Sara's big dick to slide through it and into Thea's butt, officially meaning that Sara had just taken the anal virginity of little Thea Queen. A fact which was so overwhelmingly hot to her that she almost missed the adorable little cry Thea let out as she was robbed of her butt cherry. Almost.
Instead Sara grinned wickedly and savoured the moment. After all, this wasn't just any girl that she and Nyssa had picked out of a bar or within the League of Assassins. No, this was little Thea Queen, a girl she had known for what felt like her whole life, or at least her life before the island, and would always think of as the little girl in pigtails that she would chase around the Queen Mansion now had her sexy 20-year-old body sandwiched between Sara and Nyssa. And Thea was spreading her cheeks so that Sara, and Felicity, could get the best possible view of the double penetration. God, it was so hot. And so worth it even if Oliver found out that she'd taken his sister's ass cherry.
Felicity felt super guilty for her part in all of this, not just because of Oliver but for all of Team Arrow and Thea herself. Especially the last one, as she was encouraging a younger girl into debauchery that she wouldn't have to dare to try if she hadn't been so hopelessly in love with Sara. And okay, it had worked out for her, but that didn't mean Thea wouldn't end up being emotionally scarred. Or physically. But Felicity couldn't stop watching, and now she couldn't stop fingering herself, especially as she watched her precious Sara robbing another girl of her anal virginity, a sight which should have enraged her but instead made her desperately want to cum.
Without a word Felicity had nervously moved around Thea's body so she could get the best possible look at the anal penetration while tearing off her clothes, and now she couldn't take her eyes off where Sara's big dick was slowly but surely disappearing into Thea's butt hole. That previously untouched butt hole that was being slowly filled by her girlfriend. While her other girlfriend cooed gently into Thea's ear as the poor girl was double stuffed. Fuck, how had this become her life? How had she ended up watching her girlfriend fill Thea Queen's virgin ass full of cock? And how had she ended up frantically masturbating to it?
Perhaps most importantly of all why did she immediately obey when Sara called out, "Felicity, stick your cunt in this bitch's face!"
That should have appalled Felicity, but not only did she not protest but she didn't even hesitate. Instead she walked around the bodies of the three women, crouched down and pushed her cunt Thea's face. Felicity even grabbed hold of Thea's short brown hair so she could also be shoving the younger girl's face forward to make sure Thea couldn't escape the lust which had taken over her body. Fortunately the last thing Thea seemed to want was to escape, as she held Felicity pushed her face as deep as it would go into her cunt and then immediately started licking Felicity's pussy with infectious eagerness, pausing only to moan which caused wonderful vibrations against Felicity's fuck hole.
Initially when this intense pussy licking began Felicity closed her eyes, tilted her head back and let out a long loud moan. As that meant she couldn't watch her two girlfriends DP Thea it wasn't long before Felicity opened them again, but it was a struggle to keep them open given how much Thea's eager but inexperienced tongue was getting to her, especially when the younger girl went after her clit. To be fair unlike Sara and Nyssa she hadn't yet been granted a release, and had watched while they received theirs and then started the double stuff this sexy younger woman. So Felicity didn't think it was fair to blame her for not lasting long before begging for more. And it was unlikely Sara and Nyssa would reward Thea with a orgasm until she made Felicity cum, so really Felicity was doing someone a favour here. Doing everyone a favour really.
So even though she tried to hold out for a little while it was not long before Felicity whimpered, "Please Thea, make me cum! I need to cum. Please, please, please, please, pleaseeeeeee, ooooooooh stick your tongue inside me and fuck me! Fuck me, ohhhhhhhh fuck, tongue fuck me Thea, fuck me ooooooooohhhhhhhhhh Gooooooooddddddddd yeeeeeeeeessssssssssss!"
Thea had been waiting for that command for literally hours. Or better yet years, as Felicity Smoak was irresistibly cute and ever since Thea first saw her she wanted to fuck her, and that desire had grown the more she had known her. Finally being able to do it was an honour and a privilege, one which part of Thea wished she had the patience to properly savour. But after teasing her for who knows how long by gently thrusting just over half of the dildo in and out of her ass Sara finally buried the full length in Thea's butt. Then after a few seconds to savour the moment again Sara began ass fucking Thea with every inch of that big cock while another was in her pussy. As a result Thea really wasn't in the mood to drag this out.
Instead she shoved her tongue as deep as it would go into Felicity's cunt and then hammered it in and out until she got what she wanted, namely a mouth full of girl cum. Or more accurately a face full, because when Felicity finally came it happened so fast that Thea didn't have time to react. Thea tried to make up for it, but Felicity was just cumming so hard, and there was just so much cum, and Sara was fucking her ass so good that almost all of the heavenly liquid ended up covering her face. However Thea did get to swallow some of Felicity Smoak's cum, while getting DP'ed by Sara Lance and Nyssa al Ghul no less, so it was hard to complain. Besides, she loved it when boys, and now girls, came in her face.
After what was admittedly an incredibly hard climax Felicity stumbled back and away from the three other women, which was disappointing because Thea had been hoping to lick the blonde hacker to another orgasm. She couldn't really complain though considering Sara chose that moment to pick up the pace, effortlessly sodomising Thea to the edge of orgasm, and then keeping her there just as effortlessly. Thea could instantly tell what was required of her, but it was incredibly hard for her to stop screaming in pleasure long enough to say. In the end she had to use all the mental discipline that her father and brother had taught her for ignoring pain and/or channelling it so she could beg for what she so desperately needed.
"FUCK ME! FUCK ME HARDER! AAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKK, MAKE ME CUM!" Thea screamed at the top of her lungs, "OHHHHHHHH GAWWWWWWD, I'LL DO ANYTHING, ANYTHING, JUST MAKE ME CUM! OOOOOOOOOH YESSSSSSSSS, MAKE ME CUM LIKE A SLUT! MAKE ME FUCKING CUM LIKE THE LITTLE DYKE SLUT I AM! YEEEEEEESSSSSSSS, POUND MY FUCKING FUCK HOLES AND LEAVE THEM LOOSE AND USELESS! FUCKING WRECK THEM! WRECK ME! PLEASSSSSEEEEE! PLEASE MAKE ME CUM PLEASE MAKE ME CUM PLEASE MAKE ME CUM AAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKK, OOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHH GOOOOOOOOOOODDDDDDDDDDD!"
Luckily for Thea it wasn't long before Sara ever so slightly increased her pace, instantly making her cum obscenely hard. It only got better seconds later when Nyssa started thrusting up into her pussy, the two assassins working together as Thea could only imagine how many times they had done before to Felicity and other women, effortlessly giving their lucky victim ecstasy which felt lethal. As in Thea literally thought her brain was going to explode or melt or something from the overwhelming pleasure that was turning her into a screaming and trembling wreck. And in that wonderful moment, it kind of felt like it would be worth it, just for a few more seconds of this ecstasy.
Nyssa smirked as Thea cum on her cock over and over again thanks to the combination of her thrusts and Sara's. Honestly her beloved was more than capable of gifting Thea with multiple orgasms without her, but she was tired of simply lying back and doing nothing, and wanted to make this extra special for the youngest Queen. Which was why a few minutes later when Sara began slowing down and eventually pulled her strap-on out of Thea's butt, which was far too soon in her opinion, Nyssa glared at the blonde, before grinning wickedly at the other brunette and then flipping them over. Out of courtesy to Sara she had slowed down her thrusting at the same time, and although she restarted it it was nowhere near as hard as Nyssa was capable of, or that she wanted to give the other girl right now.
Of course, it was all part of her plan, Nyssa gently stroking Thea's face before asking her, "Can I have a turn with your cute little bottom?"
"Nyssa!" Sara warned, "Don't overwhelm the poor girl. Remember she hasn't had sex in months, let alone as much as us. It's not her fault if she can't keep up."
Thea wasn't sure she could survive another orgasm, but she still whimpered, "It's okay. I, I... I want you too. Mmmmmm, fuck my ass. Fuck it hard."
"Oh honey." Sara shook her head, "You're about to regret that."
Smirking wickedly Nyssa quickly pulled her cock out of Thea's cunt and then inserted it into the younger girl's butt hole almost just as quickly, causing Thea to whimper and cry with a mixture of pain and pleasure as her well used bottom was once again violated. Those whimpers and cries quickly turned to pure pleasure as Nyssa began to gently sodomise the other girl, Thea's legs, which had been laying either side of her ever since she flipped them over, quickly wrapping around her waist and the younger brunette holding her tightly as Nyssa began showing her just how good it could feel to be butt fucked by another woman who knew exactly what she was doing.
In what felt like no time at all Nyssa had butt fucked Thea to the edge of yet another climax, and kept her there for a few long moments just to watch the small girl squirm underneath her and struggled to beg for more. Then just as Thea found the strength to utter a coherent syllable Nyssa grabbed the other brunette's legs, pulled them up to her shoulders and practically bent the poor girl in half so seconds later when she increase the pace she had a leveraged to pound Thea's butt hole as deep and as hard as possible. Fortunately Nyssa knew that Thea's training made her very flexible, so not only was this not painful for the smaller girl but she screamed in pure ecstasy as Nyssa brutalised her butt through orgasm after orgasm.
Out of the corner of her eye Nyssa could see the look of concern on Sara's face, and especially on Felicity's, but she ignored them. This girl had offered her body up to them as a sacrifice to their mutual pleasure, and from her screams of pleasure and the cum squirting out of her cunt and onto Nyssa's stomach it seemed that Thea was more than getting her fair share. Nyssa even thought that Thea would agree that her ass hole was a small price to pay for such pleasure, and if she had literally ruined it Nyssa knew a few ways to fix it. For now though she just became lost in her animal lust, Nyssa brutally pounding into her submissive mate as the stimulator on her clit and the sheer joy of roughly fucking another woman up the ass pushed Nyssa over symbolisms of her own, much like it done for Sara when she was the one abusing Thea's butt.
Sara had certainly received her fair share of orgasms, but even though she was a little jealous over the ecstasy that Nyssa and especially Thea were experiencing right now she was mostly concerned for her friend safety, which was why she studied Thea's face carefully and inevitably she yelled, "NYSSA STOP! She's unconscious!"
Nyssa was grateful for the shout out, because while she had become lost in using Thea Queen as an orifice for her pleasure she didn't like fucking unconscious bodies. She wasn't about to share that gratitude though, and instead pouted at Sara and told her, "You always have to spoil my fun."
Felicity gasped as with one fluid movement Nyssa then abruptly pulled her big dildo out of Thea's poor butt hole and then turned the other brunette over onto her front so that the three older women got a good look at the damage the assassin had done to their younger friend. That gasp was partly because of just how quick her girlfriend was, but mostly it was because of just how widely gaping Thea's ass hole was, that up until recently virgin hole looking like it would never close again, and in turn that Thea would never be able to sit properly again. It shouldn't have been a turn on, but after so much kinky sex with Sara, and more recently Sara and Nyssa, Felicity just couldn't stop staring lustfully at that ruined hole as her girlfriends argued.
"Now look what you've done." Sara grumbled.
"Yes, this is certainly the first time one of us has fucked another girl into unconsciousness." Nyssa quipped dryly.
"This isn't just some girl, we work with her." Sara pointed out, "You shouldn't have overwhelmed her like that."
"I think you underestimate her." Nyssa said, before smirking, "Or perhaps you're upset because now we don't have anyone to clean our cocks."
Despite herself Sara smirked back, "Oh, I wouldn't say that."
With that the two assassins turned to Felicity, who didn't realise their eyes were on her for a few seconds, and then she looked up and startled, "What?"
"Felicity honey..." Sara smiled sweetly, "Nyssa was mean and fucked our slut into unconsciousness. Now who's going to clean our cocks?"
"Can You think of anyone who could do that?" Nyssa smiled.
Felicity blushed, but nodded, "Yeah... I think I can."
With that Felicity got down onto her knees with the intention of shuffling over, or maybe even crawling on her hands and knees over, to her girlfriends. Instead Nyssa and Sara quickly close the distance between them, Sara getting their first and telling her, "Suck it babe. Suck Thea's ass off my dick."
Normally the reminder that the dildo in front of her had been used to butt fucked a girl was great incentive for Felicity, especially when it was her own ass that had recently been violated, but this time and caused her to hesitate. It was still very much a turn on, but a fresh batch of guilt washed over her for what she was about to do. It wasn't enough to stop her though, Felicity again blaming Sara for her slutty behaviour as she wrapped her lips around the strap-on dildo her girlfriend had used to pop the anal cherry of her boss's sister and her dear friend Thea Queen. She then moaned in pleasure at the taste, which again she blamed on Sara.
"That's it baby, suck Thea's ass off my cock." Sara grinned wickedly, "Mmmmmm, you like the taste of little Thea Queen's ass, huh? You do don't you? Oooooh, you dirty girl. Oh yeah, you tried to be good and not join in you just couldn't resist feeding Thea your sweet little pussy, and now you're sucking her little ass off my dick like the good little ATM slut you are."
"And mine." Nyssa chimed in, "Oh yes Felicity, don't forget about me. My cock is covered in ass cream too, so don't neglect it. Ooooooh yes, that's it, good girl. Clean my cock! Clean both those cocks of Oliver Queen's sister's ass hole you nasty ass to mouth bitch. Ohhhhhhh, that's hot."
It didn't take long for Felicity to switch cocks, partly because she greedily sucked the tip of Sara's cock clean in a matter of seconds and she wanted a second chance to savour the deepest part of Thea's bowels on a dick. Mostly she was hoping that it might just make her girlfriends shut up, because while up to a point she was still loving their dirty talk Felicity was extremely embarrassed that she had given in and helped defile Oliver's little sister, and naturally Nyssa and Sara were taking great delight in reminding her of that fact. Of course she didn't think it would work, and sure enough Sara and Nyssa kept talking, and even began grabbing hold of her hair and pulling her from one cock to another and then holding her in place.
Luckily Felicity was doing better at tuning them out when she wanted too, and it was easy when she had ass cream to clean. The perverted flavour also allowed Felicity to turn off her own brain for a few blissful minutes. But then of course she needed to shove the dildos deeper into her mouth and down her throat to get more anal juices until she had the entire length of first Nyssa's cock, and then Sara's, choking her windpipe. Briefly she was given another distraction in the form of Sara pulling her up into a deep kiss, the Canary moaning softly as she tasted Thea's ass on Felicity's lips. Then Nyssa took her turn with Felicity's lips, then with Sara's, before pulling back and the three girlfriends stared at each other before glancing at the still unconscious body of Thea.
"We should keep her." Nyssa said casually.
Felicity glared at her dark-haired girlfriend, "Nyssa, if we keep adding people to this relationship it's going to get ridiculous."
"I didn't mean it like that." Nyssa explained, "I meant like a pet."
"That would be hot." Sara admitted, and then when Felicity glared at her she quickly added, "Or we could just occasionally hook up with her. I think she'd be down for that. At the very least we could ask her. You know when she wakes up."
Felicity then glared at her blonde girlfriend, before biting her lip and looking over at Thea, and then after thinking about it mumbled, "Well, it couldn't hurt to at least ask."